Urgency Is a Terrible Workforce Strategist

Written by David Durbin | Nov 19, 2026, 8:38:11 PM

Think back to the last ten shifts your health system, hospital, or physician group filled at the last minute. Now ask yourself who decided how each one got filled.

Not who approved it. Who actually chose: agency, overtime, the float pool, or leaving the hole open.

For more healthcare organizations, the honest answer is nobody. Urgency decided. And urgency is quietly running the biggest cost line you have.

The decision that gets made for you

Think about how a staffing gap usually gets filled. A unit is short. A manager has a few hours. They reach for whatever is closest: an agency, overtime, a float nurse if one's free. Nobody did anything wrong. Every one of those calls made sense in the moment.

Now multiply that by every unit, every shift, every facility. You end up with a workforce strategy nobody designed. It's the sum of a thousand rushed choices, and it lands on the P&L as the largest cost category the organization has.

That's what I mean when I talk about friction. It's not only the paperwork and the extra clicks, though there's plenty of both. It's the gap between when something happens and when the right person can see it and act. The wider that gap, the more decisions get made by default.

Contract labor isn't the villain here. Agencies, travelers, and locums are essential, and sometimes they're exactly the right call. The problem is when they're the only option you could see in time.

Talent shows up too late in the plan

My colleague Josh Vesely made a point on a recent Becker's Healthcare Podcast episode that deserves more airtime. He'd just sat in a session where CFOs were talking through M&A and joint ventures, and the pattern was familiar: leaders make the growth decision, then go figure out the talent.

I'd push that further. If you're opening a service line, expanding ambulatory, or adding beds, the talent question shouldn't just come earlier. It should be able to change the answer. Whether you build, buy, or partner may hinge on whether you can staff it in that market. And every market is different. One recruiting plan stretched across five communities is really five problems wearing one coat.

When talent is an afterthought, it becomes a constraint. When it's an input, it becomes a choice.

You don't need more data. You need fresher data.

Health systems have spent real money on HR systems, scheduling platforms, and applicant tracking. Most don't need another system. They need the ones they already own to talk to each other.

Here's a test worth running: pull up the last big staffing decision your team made and ask how old the information behind it was. If the answer is 30 or 60 days, you were steering by the rear-view mirror. As Josh put it, looking backward makes it easy to see what you could have done. The value is in seeing through the windshield while there's still time to choose differently.

Visibility isn't a dashboard. It's the difference between reacting and deciding.

Automation should give time back, not take judgment away

Everyone's talking about AI. Fine. The question I care about is simpler: where are smart, capable people spending their day checking rules a system could check for them?

Timecards are a good example. So are physician travel reimbursements, where the guidelines can change facility by facility. One review might take two minutes. The next takes twenty. That's a nurse leader or department head who isn't with their team.

Let a digital worker handle the rule-checking. Flag the exceptions. Let people make the judgment calls. Nobody is handing patient care to a bot. We're handing the bot the work that keeps good leaders away from patient care.

If an automation project can't tell you how many hours it gives back to the people closest to patients, I'd ask whether it's solving the right problem.

Ownership is the whole game

This all comes down to ownership. Workforce isn't an HR line item or a procurement problem. It belongs with the CEO and CFO, with CNOs, CMOs, and CHROs carrying it every day, because it touches growth, margin, and care all at once.

And ownership isn't about control for its own sake. It's about choice. When you can see your whole workforce as one picture (core staff, internal pools, contingent talent, digital workers), you get to decide how to deploy it. When you can't, the decision gets made for you.

So, here's my challenge for the next 12 months. Don't start by buying something. Start by asking three questions:

  1. Who owns the whole workforce number, not just a piece of it?

  2. How old is the information behind our staffing decisions?

  3. Where are we spending human judgment on work a system could handle?

The answers will tell you more about your margin than any rate negotiation.

Josh and I covered more ground in our full conversation on the Becker's Healthcare Podcast, including the signals that workforce is about to limit growth and what to do when your data lives in a dozen places. Give it a listen here. Then tell me where you disagree. That's usually where the best conversations start.